mirror of
https://github.com/storytold/pdfcraft.git
synced 2026-10-14 19:27:04 -04:00
RidwanandBrandon Thomas
d9660d4e73
The parity and roadmap docs were last refreshed before a batch of fixes merged, so they still described closed issues as open problems. - #774 (encrypted output rejected by Acrobat, fixed by #836): gap 1 removed from gaps.md; its remaining interop-suite work moved to gap 12. Gap numbers are kept so existing "gap N" references stay valid. - #756 (Windows printing, #847): Printers row, Print area and roadmap rank 1 now name web printing as the remaining gap. - #740 column select (#765), #759 1:1 touchpad scrolling (#868), #810 Shift-Cmd-G (#835), #825 (#822). - #844 multi-object move (#907): marked partial, same page only. - #799, #800, #807, #809, #811, #815-#819, #821 (incl. the #816 panic): gap 6 and the area tables list them as fixed. Scores, readiness percentages and the stage are not re-judged; only the rank-0 estimate drops by gap 1's 8-15 h (40-70 -> 32-55). Co-authored-by: Brandon Thomas <[email protected]>
5.2 KiB
5.2 KiB
UI and interaction parity
Last reviewed: 2026-10-10 · Last updated: 2026-10-11 · Change: minor (column select #740, multi-object move #844, Shift-⌘-G #810 fixed) · Target: Adobe Acrobat Pro (Acrobat DC, continuous track 26.002.21931, macOS)
How PdfCraft's tools, panels, shortcuts and feel compare with Acrobat Pro's current interface (the
2023+ "new Acrobat": All tools pane on the left, quick-action toolbar, Home view). Behaviour is
observed clean-room (plan/acrobat/02-ui-ux.md, local-only; AGENTS.md §2); nothing from Adobe's
interface is copied. Gaps ranked in gaps.md.
UI/UX fidelity ≈ 55% ready (estimated), 30–60 h additional to the features total.
Measured
- 184 registered commands (
crates/engine/src/commands.rs), every one in the menus, the command palette and the automationcommand_runtool; menus are generated from the registry (view.menus-from-registry). - 141 automation tools (
crates/automation/src/tools.rs), so every UI action can be checked headlessly. - View area of the checklist: 62.5% breadth (52 shipped, 11 partial of 92).
No dump of Acrobat's menu tree has been diffed against the registry yet (gap 24).
Shell and navigation
| Element | Acrobat | PdfCraft | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
| Home view (recent files, recommended tools) | yes | yes | shipped |
| All tools pane, tool sets | yes | yes, with milestone badges | shipped |
| Quick-action toolbar, customisable | yes | fixed | partial (view.customize-quick-tools planned) |
| Command search | "Search tools" | command palette (⌘K), matches translated and English labels | shipped |
| Document tabs | yes | yes, with unsaved marker | shipped |
| Multiple windows, drag a tab out | yes | no | planned |
| Split window, spreadsheet split | yes | no | planned |
| Read mode, full screen | yes | yes | shipped; presentation options planned |
| Light, dark, system theme | yes | yes | shipped |
| Side panels: thumbnails, bookmarks, attachments, layers, comments, fields, signatures | yes | yes; panels keep their width (#704) | shipped |
| Destinations, articles, model tree, Tags, Order, Content panels | yes | no | planned |
| Message bars (restricted, signed, PDF/A, forms) | yes | restricted and signed; no PDF/A view mode | partial |
Tools, handles and precision
| Behaviour | Acrobat | PdfCraft | Status / evidence |
|---|---|---|---|
| Zoom: wheel, pinch, keys, marquee, fit page/width/height/visible | yes | yes | shipped |
| Fixed zoom percentages match Acrobat's physical size | yes | differ (#739, documented in #736) | gap |
| Dynamic zoom, loupe, pan-and-zoom window | yes | no | planned |
| Hand tool, middle-button pan, autoscroll | yes | hand tool; Linux autoscroll | partial |
| Text selection, column select | yes, Alt-drag columns | reading-order selection; Alt/Option-drag or Edit ▸ Column select (#740) | shipped |
| Select and move several objects at once | yes | on one page: Shift/Ctrl/⌘-click and marquee, one undo step (#844); not across pages, no group resize | partial |
| Object handles: corners keep proportion, edges free | yes | yes for added images and signatures | shipped |
| Arrange, align and distribute page objects | yes | fields only | partial |
| Rulers, grids, snap to grid, guides | yes | no | planned |
| Cursor coordinates, line weights | yes | no | planned |
| Measuring snap to paths, endpoints, midpoints, intersections | yes | yes | shipped |
| Nudge selected objects with arrow keys (Shift for larger steps) | yes | no: arrow keys scroll and turn pages | gap |
| Single-key tool accelerators (H, V, Z, …) | yes, opt-in | no | planned |
| Context menus on pages, thumbnails, comments, fields | yes | thumbnails, comments, fields | partial |
| Comment pop-ups as movable windows, connector lines | yes | inline in the panel | planned |
| Disabled commands explain why | no | yes | ahead |
Shortcuts and modifiers
| Item | Acrobat | PdfCraft | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
| Platform shortcuts for registered commands | yes | yes; ⌘ on macOS, Ctrl elsewhere (#695) | shipped; find bar still shows ⌘ on Windows (#746) |
| Keyboard shortcuts reference | yes | yes | shipped |
| Full keyboard operation of the app | yes | no | planned (a11y.keyboard-only, P0) |
| Shift-⌘-G finds previous | yes | yes (#810 fixed) | shipped |
Dialogs and preferences
| Item | Acrobat | PdfCraft | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
| Print dialog with preview | yes | yes | shipped |
| Document Properties (description, security, fonts, initial view, custom, advanced) | yes | all but Custom and XMP | partial |
| Field Properties (General, Appearance, Position, Options, Actions, Format, Validate, Calculate, Signed) | yes | all but Signed | partial |
| Comment properties and properties bar | yes | yes | shipped |
| Preferences | ≈ 20 pages | Interface language, Documents and view, Identity, Fill & Sign, JavaScript | partial (gap 19) |
Revision history
| Date | Change | Summary |
|---|---|---|
| 2026-10-11 | minor | Column select shipped (#740, PR #765); several objects move together on one page (#844, PR #907); Shift-⌘-G goes back (#810, PR #835) |
| 2026-10-10 | major | Created from the command registry, automation tools, the View area of the checklist and open UI issues |